Search This Blog

Tuesday, May 10, 2016

Hedge Funds: A Great Deal for The Managers...as for the Investors..It's Quite a Different Story

NYT


Hedge Funds Faced Choppy Waters in 2015, but Chiefs Cashed In



For many managers, collecting large pay, even when performance was not tops, has become a side effect of growing bigger.
“Is the goal to continue to make money in a risky environment or is the goal to preserve assets on which you collect fees?” Mr. Petzel added.
Other managers hauled in large pay packages despite losing some of their investors money.
Daniel Och, the founder of the Och-Ziff Capital Management Group, made $140 million in 2015. His firm’s flagship fund, OZ Master Fund, lost 0.28 percent last year. Other funds within the firm fared well, with its OZ Asia Master Fund up 9.64 percent.
But the firm has come under regulatory scrutiny over whether its dealings in Africa violated the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act. The publicly listed hedge fund firm has set aside $200 million to deal with a potential regulatory action.
Michael Platt, the founder of BlueCrest Capital Management, took home $260 million, according to Alpha. It was a difficult year for his firm, once one of the biggest hedge funds in Europe with $37 billion in investor money. He lost investors in his flagship fund 0.63 percent over the year and then told them he was throwing in the towel.

Reit Update

I posted on the possible buying pressure that might give a lift to REITs because on index reconstitution on Tuesday May 3 (citing analyst reports and press reports)

As of May 9 close RWR the S+P REIT ETF hit a 52 week high and was up from a close of 94.06 on May 3 to a close of 97.76 on the 9th a bit under 4%

10 day chart (15 minute intervals) for RWR


Alliance Bernstein Throws in the Towel in the Active vs Passive(indexing) Management Debate: Active Can't Best Passive

Kudos for their honesty..but don't expect them to close down their actively managed mutual funds or their stock picking and market timing "separately managed accounts".

From the FT


AllianceBernstein chief says active management ‘too big’

Robin Wigglesworth, US Markets Editor




The asset management industry has grown too bloated to consistently produce market-beating returns and needs to be more disciplined on size to restore investor faith, according to the head of one of the biggest US investment houses.

Money has gushed out of traditional stockpicking funds in recent years and into cheap “passive” strategies such as exchange traded funds, as most portfolio managers have proven increasingly unable to consistently beat their benchmarks after fees.

Monday, May 9, 2016

About that Currency Market Timing




I blogged Friday about the WSJ article that noted
The U.S. dollar’s weakness this year has shown the downside of hedging currency exposure when investing in overseas stocks.
Investors are taking note, pulling money out of currency-hedged exchange-traded funds after heavy buying last year, as the funds proliferated.
The rush of money into the hedged funds—and the recent movement out—is evidence that investors were chasing performance, says Ben Johnson, director of global ETF research at Morningstar Inc.
Investors “have a near-zero chance of regularly and effectively timing currency movements,” Mr. Johnson says.


Bloomberg this morning

Just when investors thought they’d finally made a good call in the currency market, the dollar’s advance messed it up.
The U.S. currency on Friday capped its best week all year versus its major peers, shortly after hedge funds finally switched to betting on dollar declines, known as going short. That’s not the only wrong move foreign-exchange managers have made this year -- an index tracking their returns shows they’ve failed to turn a profit in 2016.

Friday, May 6, 2016

More Evidence of Performance Chasing This Time in Currency Hedging ..and Many "Professional Advisors" are no Better than Anyone Else

WSJ

The Downside of Hedging Currency Risk for Stock Investors

Investors are pulling money out of currency-hedged exchange-traded funds after heavy buying last year  

The U.S. dollar’s weakness this year has shown the downside of hedging currency exposure when investing in overseas stocks.

Investors are taking note, pulling money out of currency-hedged exchange-traded funds after heavy buying last year, as the funds proliferated.
The rush of money into the hedged funds—and the recent movement out—is evidence that investors were chasing performance, says Ben Johnson, director of global ETF research at Morningstar Inc. MORN 0.55 %
Investors “have a near-zero chance of regularly and effectively timing currency movements,” Mr. Johnson says....

The outflows from currency-hedged ETFs tracked by Morningstar began in September. After taking in nearly $41.8 billion from January through August of 2015, the funds experienced net outflows of $1.8 billion from September through December. Nearly $6.5 billion more flowed out in the first three months of this year, says Morningstar, which currently tracks 48 currency-hedged ETFs.
There is an argument to be made for consistently hedging currency exposure—to focus on the returns of the underlying securities—and one for accepting currency risk as another variable in a diversified portfolio. But shifting between hedged and unhedged investments is essentially another variation of market timing and tough to do successfully.
“People are chasing the performance of the U.S. dollar,” says Paul Bosse, a principal in the Vanguard Group’s investment strategy group. “Is that really a surprise? We’ve seen those sorts of chasings go throughout the years

He says the decision to hedge currency exposure should be “a long-term position; it’s not an on/off switch.”
Some advisers who moved into hedged international-stock funds in recent years sold as they became less bullish on international shares in general.
For example, Jeffrey Carbone, co-founder and senior partner at Cornerstone Financial Partners Inc. in Huntersville, N.C., began investing in a dollar-hedged European-stock ETF in December 2014. But seeing slow global growth and anticipating a weaker dollar, he sold a portion of that position last year and the remainder in January. Mr. Carbone says his portfolio is now overweight in U.S. stocks and underweight in international equities.

Thursday, May 5, 2016

This is What is Known in The Investment Business as Talking Your Book

In my earlier post about Bond guru Bill Gross I mentioned Jeff Gundlach the new "Bond King" who is attracting billions in assets with his own unconstrained bond fund. Like Gross he takes large concentrated positions with weightings far different than the total bond market index.

One well know technique of thse gurus is to get on as much as the media as possible promoting positions which you have taken in your portfolio. Nothing like a little extra buying from the guru followers to help the short term postion of your portfolio. Of course you can be sure this manager will have sold out his position before he starts appearing all over the media announcing his changed views of the market.

Via Bloomberg
Gundlach’s $59 billion DoubleLine Total Return Bond Fund has returned about 2 percent in 2016, compared with a 3.5 percent gain by the Barclays U.S. Aggregate Bond Index, the main benchmark for the broader bond market. The fund beat 98 percent of peers over the past five years, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
Gundlach also recommended shorting utilities stocks and buying mortgage real-estate investment trusts, both through exchange-traded funds. With one turn of leverage, the trade should rise by 35 percent, he said.
Last month Gundlach told investors that it would be a good time to buy mortgage-backed securities and sell corporate bonds

And here is the  breakdown of Gundlachs Doubleline Total Return'Bond Fund's holdings showing it with an 83% weighting in mortgage back securities vs. a category average of just under 30%.


Can Those Robo Advisors Meet the Fiduciary Standard of Always Working in The Clients' Best Interests ?




I have written several times including here and here  about the shortcomings of "robo advisors". I noted that these services are unlikely to offer a comprehensive investment management that best meets the needs of investors.


Because of the structure of these advisory services they seldom get an in depth knowledge of the investors financial life,tax situation or even a full picture of their investment assets. They create the portfolio based on a short questionnaire then implement an allocation chosen from a set of models that are "cookie cutter". There is no opportunity for personal interaction with the client to explain the portfolio allocation in depth or to learn about changes in the clients personal circumstances.

Since these services are licensed as registered investment advisors they are held to the fiduciarcy standard of always acting in the clients best interests. Although the services charge low management fees and make use of low cost ETFs, and use long term strategies with rebalancing and no short term trading--all important elements of a good investment strategy-- many are asking if that is sufficient to meet the fiduciary standard. 

Those raising this issue include regulators and legal experts as the NYT recently reported


Many of the points raised here are the same as those I raised in my posts

A robo-adviser does not ask about money held outside of its service, for example, which can provide a distorted picture of a customer’s financial standing. Others argue the robo-advisers try to wiggle out of too much responsibility in their customer agreements.The Massachusetts Securities Division recently put investors and the state-registered investment advisers it oversees — or those with less than $100 million in assets — on notice. In a paper issued this month, it bluntly stated that it did not believe an algorithm alone was capable of serving as a fiduciary, at least not the way robo-advisers are structured now.“I am not sure that many investors, in many cases, can be adequately taken care of by answering questions,” said William F. Galvin, Massachusetts secretary of the commonwealth, who likened the services to driverless cars. “You need a human that is responding to them.’’Arthur Laby, a professor at Rutgers Law School, said investment advisers, as fiduciaries, can limit the breadth of their relationship with clients. Still, he does not view robo-advisers as fiduciaries in the traditional sense because of their inability to address subtleties that may arise in conversation.“They are not able to provide the kind of personalized advice that a customer can get from a human on the phone or sitting across the desk, where the customer can say: ‘Oh, I have a new wrinkle. I might be inheriting assets in the next 12 months,’” he said. “Or: ‘I may need to care for a sick parent. How will that impact the cash I need?’.... last May, the S.E.C. and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, or Finra, jointly issued an investor alert on automated investment services that highlighted their risks and limitations. For example, these services may suggest a certain mix of investments, the regulators said, but not realize that the investor needs some of the money in a few years to buy a new home.

Others acknowledge the shortcomings of the" robos" while still arguing they can still meet the fiduciary standard:

Many robo-advisers say that they make their limits clear, noting that they are not in the business of providing full-scale financial planning. But often that kind of information is buried in the fine print.Being a “fiduciary is not about the types of service you offer, it’s about the quality of service,” said Adam Nash, chief executive of Wealthfront, a robo-adviser managing more than $3 billion. “There are financial planners helping you figure out what type of house you should buy. It’s not required that everyone do that.”

I am certainly no expert on the legal nuances of what constitutes adequate service to meet a fiduciary standard. It is clear --even in the view of the head of one of the largest robo advisors--that their service is far less comprehensive than what an investor would get from a personalized relationship with a human being.

With the internal management fees of many exchange traded funds now under .10% it might be worthwhile for investors to consider whether or not and advisory fee of .8 to 1% (remember that fees on this service are tax deductible) in exchange for personalized advice might make more economic sense than paying .25% to a "robo advisor". 

For example: a couple with assets split between taxable accounts, IRAs and 401ks simply working with an advisor that looks at all of those accounts comprehensively and is sure to allocate in one comprehensive tax sensitive investment strategy could easily offset the additional fees paid to the "non robot".


Continue reading the main story