Search This Blog

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

While You May Not Have Been Looking...European Stocks Are Outperforming the US and Emerging Markets Have Turned Up

The two major European stock etfs VGK and FEZ have now outpaced the US market performance over the past 12 months and Germany (EWG) which strongly outperformed the US in 2012 is not far behind over that same period .

Below is a chart with SPY (S+P 500) and total US Market (VTI) comparison (colors for labels are the same is on bar chart and the top graph which is growth of $100,000)

Emerging markets are way behind but have turned up of late with EEMV which I have written about outperforming IEMG which I mentioned in the same article as an alternative to VWO has outperformed over the last 12 months.I wrote about adding IEMG and EEMV to portfolios as an alternative to VWO here.

IEMG EEMV, VWO  and VTI below, return and volatility in bar chart below growth of $100,000 in line chart.


I have written about the relative valuations of US and international stocks in my review of the first quarter.

Friday, May 3, 2013

An Unusual ETF That Looks Interestng

Readers of this blog know that I am not a fan of hgh management fees and not much of a believer in active management....

Yet a relatively new ETF that carries high fees and is actively managed looks quite interesting to me.

The ETF is HYLD the Petrius High Yield Bond ETF , it is an actively managed high yield bond fund with a management fee of (ouch) 1.35%.

One reason I am not a fan of actively managed bond funds is that they are often "go anywhere bond fund" like Pimco's Total Return which makes macro bets (positioning) across maturities and types of bonds. Even with Mr. Gross' admirable management record I don't like the fund because in building a bond portfolio one never knows how the fund is positioned. Thus it is impossible to structure a bond allocation with particular targets in terms of credit quality and duration with such a fund. Other funds, even when labelled for a particular part of the market, can drift away from the prospectus title and have a poor record of consistently outperforming the benchmark.

On the other hand, I have felt that there is potential for success in active management of bonds within a defined level of credit quality and duration. After all bond market prices (on a relative basis in the same sector and duration) are determined by the issuer's creditworthiness. This is determined by slower moving and less volatile factors : major changes in income, changes in balance sheet rather than the more volatile  earnings and revenue that determines stock prices.  The ultimate risk to a bondholder is bankruptcy and even in bankruptcy bondholders will receive something and are senior to holders of equity.

 So good credit analysis/active management does have the potential for outperformance.

That is why HYLD looks interesting. It confines itself to a specific sector of the credit market: short term high yield. As I have noted in my credit market review, this sector offers an attractive risk reward profile. The low duration reduces interest rate risk and also diminishes credit risk . While credit spreads have indeed declined already the lower interest rates reduce debt service costs.

Should economic conditions improve that wouldwould increase the debt issuer's cashflow and ability to service debt..effectively reducing the credit risk of high yield bond. While the narrowing of credit spreads between high yield and treasury bonds has raised some warnings of a "bubble" the truth may be that short term high yield has extremely attractive risk/reward characteristics compared to the rest of the bond market.

The index ETF for short term high yield (SJNK) looks attractive and HYLD may be an attractive addition to short term high yield allocation in a bond portfolio.

Petrius explains its methodology here. Essentially it is value investing within the short term high yield sector.
As the manager explains it: in a paper on alpha and beta in bond investing.


What is important for investors to understand about value investing in bonds versus stocks is that we have a natural exit strategy
in that we have a maturity date with a price of par ($100). Value investing in the equity business means that you can own a cheap
stock and it can stay cheap forever. Most importantly, the analysis on bonds is entirely different than stocks. Why? Our returns don’t
depend upon beating expectations or earnings growth or great stories or any of that nonsense. What we care about is the company’s
ability to pay its bills, including our interest payment, until that maturity date, or an earlier refinancing or call. So our analysis centers
on our core philosophy: CREDIT IS EITHER AAA OR D! What we mean by this is that if we believe that the company can pay all its
bills for the foreseeable future, then it is an AAA credit to us. If we believe it cannot, we put it in the “D” camp, which means we feel
it has a high likelihood of default and we will choose not to invest in it



In other words if they can locate a bond with an attractive yield short maturity and good credit prospects as long as the bond is paid back (the exit point) the active market selection will be profitable.

So far so good for HYLD.

Here is a comparison of HYLD  and SJNK

HYLD                                                                  SJNK
Duration                            3.1 years                     1.99 years
30 day SEC Yield                8.1%                         4.07%
% of assets rated below b-  17%                           19.2%

One Year Performance and Volatility are listed below . Clearly on a risk/return basis HYLD looks quite attractive. Interestingly and not surprisingly the outperformance of hyld vs sjnk is almost identical to the yield differential of 4%.

The high total return which is in excess over the yield is capital appreciation due to compression of credit spreads. But going forward an investor in either of these ETFs would be happy with no fluctuation in price and simply  collect the yield of investment grade short term bonds of around 2%. And looking at the relative yields investors in SJNK could tolerate some reversal in the credit spreads and declines in price and still have a total return above that of investment grade bonds. That cushion vs investment grade is even greater for HYLD.

Of course the caveats remain: the fees are .95% above that of SJNK, the fund has been around only since Nov 2010 so the track record is short. Liquidity is not great , a good rule of thumb is never to enter market orders and to always use limit orders, this would particularly the case for this ETF.

Using HYLD in a bond portfolio:
 I have written before about the concept of a credit barbell as opposed to the more common barbell strategy combing long and short maturities to modify interest rate risk.

In a credit barbell one would remain in the same duration but lower the credit risk by combining high and low risk.

A simple and  risk averse strategy would be to combine SJNK, HYLD and the short term treasury ETF SHY.  SHY pays virtually no interest and this point, but it gives a bit of a crisis hedge. Should a serious crisis like in 2008 occur, SHY will likely increased in value.

In 2008 SHY increased in value by 6.6%, short term high yield etfs were not available, but as a bit of a point of comparison intermediate term high yield declined by 24.7% and short term investment grade declined by 6.6%. I would expect short term high yield to show a decline somewhere between that number. Using a conservative number of 20% decline for HYLD that would mean a 50% SHY 25% SJNK and 25% HYLD   portfolio would return somewhere in the are of -7%. Not terrible for a disaster scenario considering the current yield on the portfolio would be that would carry 3%  compared to 1.1% for short term investment grade bonds (VCSH).

And high yield has a strong reversion to the mean. In 2009  JNK returned over 37%


Monday, April 22, 2013

Top Performing Sectors = Telecom and Utilities and The Are Expensive


The always sharp folk at Bespoke Investments posted this interesting  article and the graph below:



Clients and regular readers of this site know that we have had a longstanding preference for US stocks with domestic exposure over stocks that generate the bulk of their revenues outside of the United States.  A look at the chart below shows just how well that strategy has been working over the last year.  In the chart, we compare the one-year performance of all ten S&P 500 sectors (y-axis) to the percentage of domestic revenues for the average stock in the sector (x-axis).
As shown, Technology is the only S&P 500 sector that is down over the last year, and it also happens to be the only sector where the average stock generates less than half of its revenues in the United States.  On the opposite end of the spectrum, stocks in the Telecom Services sector generate the largest percentage of their revenues in the United States, and Telecom has seen the best performance over the last year.  Besides these two sectors, if you look at the rest of the sectors in the S&P 500, there is a clear trend between percentage of domestic revenues and performance over the last year; the more the better.
__________________________________________________________________
I would give an additional..or alternative explanation. The stocks in those sectors carry high dividends. And the conventional wisdom" or even, judging by the blogosphere investing craza is dividend ("dividend growth") iinvesting.
Here are the current p/es and yields for the sectors  (all via morningstar.com)
XLUutilities p/e 16 yield 3.72%
XTL telecom p/e 24.7 yield 3%
S+P 500  p/e 14 yield 2%
VTI total US market p/e 13.57  yields 2%

Stocks in the above sectors generally trade at a valuation discount to the overall market

Thursday, April 18, 2013

Q 1 2013 Credit Market Review and Strategy


If there was a message of the fixed income (bond) market this quarter it was that investors have finally decided that the risk return on intermediate and longer term bonds has tilted away from bonds. This triggered a small selloff in intermediate and longer term bonds in anticipation of an eventual end to Federal Reserve’s easing policy if not through outright interest rate increases at least in the form of an end or reduction in bond buying (“quantitative easing/QE). Nonetheless, with economic data mixed there is certainly no decisive “bursting” of the bond bubble.
It seems as if the close to 20 years of largest in history declines in interest rates (see below for 10 year treasury and corporate investment grade bonds since 1963 ) is running to a close. Simply on the basis of arithmetic, since rates cannot go below zero, the gains of previous years simply cannot be replicated.
Intermediate Term Bonds (Treasuries Blue, Corporates Red)



Nonetheless as of this writing (April 16)recent economic data still point to weakness in the economy and low near term inflation giving some gains to intermediate and longer term bonds. We still see the risk/return as with one exception—Build America Bonds—as unattractive.
Treasury bonds:                         
Treasury bonds carrying the lowest yield of all sectors of the bond market performed the worst of the key bond sectors as seen below The low yields were not enough to offset much of the price changes.

Investment Grade Corporate Bond
Investors willing to take moderate credit risk were rewarded for taking the risk with modest gains.

High Yield (junk bonds) Investors in search of yield have invested record amounts into high yield bonds pushing yields and credit spreads to record lows. The conventional wisdom is full of talk of a high yield bond “bubble”.  I view that analysis as simplistic. If the major cause for higher interest rates is an improved economy than it doesn’t follow that high yield bonds will suffer more than other bonds of similar maturity in the treasury and investment grade sectors. After all the low rates mean  that companies have refinanced at lower rates that factor and an improved economy would mean better prospects for the weaker credits that issue high yield debt.

Strategy: Finding value in the bond market.


Risks of price declines in bonds that reduce or erase total returns (interest earned + price change) come in two types: credit risk and interest rate risk.

Interest rate risk: Higher market interest rates cause declines in the bond market and the longer the maturity (or more precisely duration) of bonds the greater the price declines. Based on current market levels the risk return of intermediate and long term bonds argues for shortening maturities despite the lower yields.

Credit Risk: In terms of risk/reward tradeoff taking on a higher credit risk seems a better way to pick up yield. As noted an improved economy reduces credit risk and short term bonds carry minimal interest rate risk as their price sensitivity to interest rate changes is far lower than on intermediate or long term bonds.

This would argue for looking at the following mutual funds and ETfs s as components of a bond market allocation. '

In a conservative allocation such  one is just looking for minimal price fluctuation such that total return = yield for the short term bonds and a price risk that is high enough to offset price fluctuations for the intermediate term bond fund…with some potential for upside.


  • GNMA bond funds: these funds are short duration and the instruments carry the full faith and credit of the US Government but have yields above treasuries. Although recent total return has been hurt by the vagaries of Fed purchases of mortgage securitie they still merit considering in asset allocation.  Current 30 day sec yield is 1.69%
  • Short term investment grade corporate bonds…a little more credit risk than the above  for a bit higher yield  and a bit more price volatility 
  • Short term high yield bonds. For those willing to take on more credit risk short term high yield (SJNK) looks quite attractive. The yield is around 4.25% and the price has proven to be very stable. All an investor is looking for in this area of the bond market is minimal price movement allowing the investor to capture the yield.
  • Intermediate term bonds. For those willing to take on a bit of interest rate risk as a “hedge” against going all in on a view of rates going higher in the near term there is one sector of the intermediate bond market where risk/return look reasonable. Build America Bonds essentially muni bonds with the Federal government assuming partially the cost of debt payments. In other words these bonds offer a cushion against possible price declines due to higher interest rates and good potential for price increases should rates move down a bit  BAB currently yields a bit over 4%/
  • Treasury bills instead of money market. Investors who currently have some holdings in money market funds might consider a tbill etf like SHY as an alternative.  Money market funds are not credit risk free in 2008 a major money market fund “broke the buck” fell below $1 in net asset value. Although the Fed effectively bailed out the fund and its investors to protect the $1 net asset value, there is no guarantee this will occur in the future. On the other hand treasury bills are a crisis hedge.                                                                        Despite their near zero current yield they are likely to rise in price in a financial crisis. In 2008 SHY had a total return of 6%  while money market returns guaranteed no price fluctuation but paid virtually zero interest  making total return = yield . And  money marke funds carry more credit risk than treasury bills. Thus treasury bills act as a bit of a “crisis hedge”. 
  • ” Combining some treasury bills with short term high yield in their portfolio. This would be a “barbell strategy “with regard to credit risk while retaining low interest rate risk. As rough example a 50/50 split between SJNk and SHY would yield  a bit over 2.55%    Of course increasing the weighting of SJNK would raise yield--(and increase credit risk—risk and return are (almost) always linked at the hip.

Thursday, April 11, 2013

Q1 2013 Equity Market Review and A Look Ahead:


The first quarter was a very strong one for US equity markets with far weaker performance outside the US:
US total stock market (ETF VTI)                                       11%
Developed International Markets (EFA)                      3.7%
Emerging Markets (VWO)                                           + 3.7%
If the  US market rally continues at this rate for the entire year it would mean  increase would represent a 40% + gain for 2013 which Is to say the least highly unlikely.  
We remain skeptical of the recent price increases and within the discipline of our long term strategy have reduced our exposure to US stocks.
What are the common explanations for the market rally?
 Here is a rundown of the “conventional wisdom” and my skeptical response
·         Because of low interest rates and uncertainty outside of the US investors have “no place else” to put their money.
True, US interest rates are at record lows and the high valuation of many high dividend stocks that considered stable but low growth indicates many investors are ---erroneously in my view—looking at dividend stocks as a substitute for bonds.  Indicative of this is that consumer defensive stocks considered slower growing, but higher dividend stocks and utilities are top performing sectors year to date. These stocks generally trade at a valuation discount to the SP 500 but are now trading at premium of over 10%.

The curious part of this explanation is that the bond market as reflected in market prices —and the conventional wisdom of the bond market analysts—is that the end of the Feds aggressive easing policy is nearing. So if the equity rally is because of low interest rates and bonds are  highly risky due to the prospect of higher  interest rates it seems that low interest rates are a thin reed upon which to base a 10%+ rally over 3 months…the message of the bond market that the major declines in interest rates are behind us.
·         A “great rotation” is occurring in which investors are returning to stocks after missing most of the markets recovery
Great rotation is too strong a term particularly if it represents the beginning of a long term major return of individual investors into the stock market. Anecdotal and fund flow data definitely do show movement of individual investors back into stock funds and ETFs. But individual investors (and the fund managers who try to “catch up” with the market to avoid outflows and attract inflows) can be a fickle lot and many of them will likely flee from the market at the first sign of a selloff.
·         Price Momentum: Markets definitely have a momentum factor in which short term trends are self-reinforcing. That makes market timing –trying to pick tops and bottoms—virtually impossible. But high returns make markets more risky, price can deviate from value in the short term and markets tend to revert to the mean. High current returns and valuations portend lower returns in the future. All this means that rebalancing  makes sense in response to large market moves (in this case selling stocks and readjusting allocations) but moving all in or all out is  not a path for long term investing success
·         Improved economic outlook in the US.  At the end of the 2012 all the conventional wisdom was forecasting a reversal of the modest of the emerging economic recovery due to the sequester, payroll tax increases and assorted other woes. None of this has changed since the turn of the year , yet the market has shown the strong performance. Macro-economic data particularly in housing show the economy has likely bottomed. But the growth prospects are still modest at best, the employment data and consumer spending and confidence data don’t point to anything close to economic growth above 2.5 -3% with the potential for negative surprises  larger than those for unexpectedly good news.  The anemic employment figures released on April 5 are a good sign of how fragile the recovery is.

 Furthermore, the stronger the economic data the greater the prospects for a change in Fed policy….and higher rates are unlikely to be good for stocks.
·         Improved corporate profitability: corporate profitability has improved led largely by the recovery of the devastated housing and financial sectors. Consumer spending has not shown a major upturn. 
Furthermore, investors have been bidding up the prices of stocks of large cap high dividend payers many of which are major multinationals with large portions of their revenues coming from outside the US. If the message of the European and Emerging economy equity markets is for slow growth and profitability among those companies there has to be a limit to the prospective profit growth of US multinationals like Procter and Gamble, Ford and McDonalds who depend on foreign markets for a large portion of their profits.
·         US markets attractive vs. the rest of the world:  The situation in Europe and slower growth in emerging economies certainly raise the risk levels in these markets…but in a global economy does that mean that equity holdings in non US economies justify the divergent performance and valuations are likely to continue? 
·         Valuations are reasonable:  At the end of the day stock prices can go up one of two ways: increased profits or higher valuations (i.e. one dollar invested buying a smaller portion of future earnings because of optimism about the future).
The best long term measure of valuation is the CAPE or Schiller P/E ratio which is based on the average of 10 years of earnings.  Markets with high valuations as measured by CAPE have shown to have poor investment returns going forward. The current US S+P 500 P/E are 23.18 well above the historical mean of 16.47. The Price earnings P/E ratio based on 12 month trailing earnings is 17.93 vs. a long term mean of 15.49. In other words the market is anticipating a sustained recovery in earnings….despite economic uncertainty around the world. It is hard for to see the US market as undervalued.

Based on most valuation measures the US market is highly valued although certainly not at “bubble” levels Despite  appearances …the higher the market returns the higher risk and the lower the prospective returns indicating   caution is in order and the prospects of a “correction” in the near term is high. 

Will the pattern of recent years with a selloff after a first quarter (see below) repeat itself? With the large price indices of the past quarter….it seems a reasonable scenario.




.

Investment implications   my general investment approach   makes use of portfolio rebalancing, but large scale market timing and believes that “price and value” can deviate in the short term but revert to the mean in the long term.  My current outlook and strategy is based upon:  Rebalancing between asset classes has been shown to increase return modestly and at lower risk (volatility)

Rebalancing portfolios A rebalancing strategy would take some profits on equity positions and  moving to fixed income (more on fixed income strategy in my next email) in order to keep portfolios slightly underinvested in equities vs. target allocations. Of course investing this way goes the opposite of the tendency to buy into momentum. That strategy runs the risk of buying high and selling low. Although rebalancing certainly runs the risk of missing out on some of the moves due to momentum…as has likely been the case for rebalances that have missed the most recent part of the market’s strong rally.

Global Allocations

With global valuations as follows (relevant ETF listed in parentheses) price/prospective earnings

US S+P 500 (SPY) 13.5
Europe (VGK) 11.3
Germany (EWG) 12.8
Emerging Markets (IEMG) 10.95
Emerging Asia (11.38)

It is hard to find a rationale for favoring US over non US stocks for the medium to longer term.

The major US and European indices are heavily weighted with global multinationals that compete with each other around the world; it is hard to rationalize European multinationals trading at a 15% valuation discount to the US peers.

Emerging market economies have slowed from their very rapid growth of previous years but still have stronger long term growth prospects than the US.  These indices include both major multinationals such as Samsung as well as domestically oriented companies like China mobile.   Growth has slowed significantly in China, India, South Korea and Brazil but longer term growth prospects and demographic trends remain positive.

Ironically one of the hot “new ideas” for investing is to invest in merging market corporate government and corporate bonds because of the better economic fundamentals vs. the US. If that is the case and if the major growth market for US multinationals is in the emerging economies then a longer term perspective would see emerging market stocks trading at a 20% discount to US stocks as a buying opportunity.

A valuation based investor looking to initiate new equity positions would likely look outside the US and rebalancers might wind up selling US stocks and adding to their international allocation.

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

Morningstar Agrees With Me on Emerging Markets ETF

I wrote about alternative emerging maarkets ETF strategies emphasizing low volatility strategies here

Morningstar reached similar conclusions here:


Are There Better Emerging-Markets ETF Choices?


Saturday, March 16, 2013

Rethinking A Bond ETF Allocation...The RIght Way and The Wrong Way

The March 11 WSJ features on of the almost endless stream of articles about preparing for the time when interest rates, rise. The articles range from sensible to apocalyptic with some predicting a quick and massive "bursting of the bond bubble".

First off its interesting to me that so many articles worry about the impact of a rise in interest rates on the bond market but seem to ignore it with regards to its impact on stock prices.

Thus the WSJ article starts out as follows:


"Don't fight the Fed" has been a market mantra for the past four years. But some bond investors are starting to lace on their gloves.

Figuring that the Federal Reserve won't be able to keep a lid on interest rates forever, large money managers such as BlackRock Inc., BLK -0.08% TCW Group Inc. and Pacific Investment Management Co. are getting ready for the day when rates take their first turn higher. 
It isn't coming anytime soon, these investors say. But when it does, they worry, the ascent will be swift and steep.
Of course the"don't fight the Fed mantra" is part of stock market lore too. And if there is one thing that pundits endlessly stress in their explanations of the stock markets rise it is the Fed policy of low interest rates which has pushed investors into riskier assets including stocks. In other words there is ample reason to be concerned that a change in interest rate policy will lead to a stock selloff that could be swift and steep as welll. And given that stocks are more volatile than bonds it is the stock market reaction to higher rates that may be more painful.
But back to bond allocations.
  • In establishing a bond portfolio it is easier to pinpoint the risk factors and potential risk return of alternative scenarios. While it may not be possible to predict when interest rates will change it is relatively straightforward to predict how various types of bonds will react to changes in interest rates.
  • Don't forget the total return: many articles on bonds focus solely on price changes ignoring the total return which is a product of price changes and interest earned. 
Despite the many words written on the bond market and the oft repeated warning of a "bond bubble" these same articles are very imprecise in explaining where exactly they see the "bubble" and therefore which bonds are at risk of big losses due to "bubble bursting". I have seen the term applied to high yield bonds, corporate bonds and treasury bonds often with little specificity as to maturity.

So here is an effort at clarity and specificity

Of course bond prices and yields move in opposite directions. And longer term bonds are more sensitive to changes in interest rates than short term bonds. The unprecedented declines in longer term interest rates has led to massive price increases. People have called the rise in prices in long term rates a "bubble" for several years but prices have continued to rise(yields fall). 

Unlike stocks which theoretically have unlimited upside bond prices cannot rise forever (interest rates can not fall forever). Therefore it is a simple mathematical certainty that long term bond investors will not experience the total return gains they have experienced in the last  years when for example 10 year treasury bond yields fell from over 5% to under 2.5%. Looking further back on the long term chart of bond yields below, it is clear that the gains to holders of bonds over the past decades will not be repeated in the future ...it is simply mathematically impossible, interest rates cannot fall below zero.

So from a strictly mathematical point of view the risk/return to holding longer term bonds is skewed negatively. The downside risk is greater than the upside potential for longer term bonds. 

Credit Risk: The other factor affecting bond prices is credit risk i.e. market perception of the potential inability of the issuer to pay back the bond holder. When using ETFs one is investing by asset class therefore diversifying away the individual company risk in the bond portfolio.

Investors can increase their credit risk and increase their yields through moving from treasury bonds to investment grade coporate bonds or even to riskier high yield bonds.

Spreads: the interest rate differential between treasury bonds and coporate bonds of both investment grade and high yield have narrowed at the same time that interest rates have declined. See chart. below.

But are high yield bonds in a  "bubble " ? Here is where I think alot of the analysis gets very sloppy. The Federal Reserve has told the world that it will only raise interest rates when economic conditions improve. But when economic conditions improve so should the fortunes of the financially weaker companies that issue high yield bonds. In other words their ability to repay their debt should improve...lowering the risk of default. Remember that in the beginnings of the economic crisis in 2008 as treasury bond interest rates fell, high yield bond interest rates moved up sharply (the spreads increased). Investors in the intermediate term HYG high yield bond ETF  suffered a loss of over 17% in 2008 while investors in intermediate term treasury ETF (ITE) had a gain of over 11%.

In other words better economic conditions lead to higher interest rates across the board lead to price changes which are greater as the maturity/duration increases. But there is no reason to assume they will affect high yield (junk) bonds more negatively than Treasury bonds.

 Long term bonds may be in a "bubble" or at least have poor risk reward characteristics but it is because of maturity not credit quality. 

In other words its the maturity/duration not the credit quality that should be the most important concern in establishing a bond etf portfolio.