Search This Blog

Friday, May 15, 2009

Always Late to the Party


The NYT writes about how investors that fled stocks at the end of the year are now, after the s+p 500 has risen about 32% since early March getting back into stocks (see the s+p ytd above). Human nature never changes and people often perceive risk incorrectly seeing stocks as less risky after a big move up and more risky after a big move down. In fact the reverse is the case and those like us that never fully liquidated our stocks were in for the quick rally.

The crowd will probably give the market some more upward momentum which we are happy to ride. But fairly soon we will sell off some of our gains to kept our asset allocation in line and buy more if there is a significant market drop to keep at our asset allocation. Of course if experience is any indicator many individual investors will be buying more on the further rally and selling at the selloff.

And note how the individual investors mentioned ignore some basic rules to avoid: over concentration in a single industry, avoiding lottery ticket small cap growth stocks which have a good story but dont necessarily make good stocks. Unlike Peter Lynch's advice years ago to buy stocks based on your experience with the product evidence shows it is ofen not the case (sirius and xm, boston chicken etc)

From the NYT(my bolds)

May 16, 2009
Testing Wall St.’s Waters, but Not Getting in Too Deep
By JACK HEALY

A woman on Long Island opened an Ameritrade account and started buying stock in mining companies. In Chicago, a developer in advertising is betting heavily on oil. And outside Seattle, a Microsoft employee is snapping up shares of technology firms and retailers.

After being pummeled in Wall Street’s plunge last year, many small investors pulled out of stocks. But the stock market’s recent rally — one of the sharpest since World War II — is starting to beckon some of them back.

So step by nervous step, some smaller investors are beginning to tiptoe back in. They are pulling money out of their savings accounts and money market funds and buying stocks and bonds, fingers crossed....


Still, some investors smell profits in the wind, and are ready to come out of hiding and try to make money again. In Wall Street’s endless battle between fear and greed, they are starting to feel the tug of greed.

Investments in safe but low-yielding money market mutual funds have fallen by $117 billion from their record highs in mid-January through this week, according to iMoneyNet. As people began to look for higher returns on their money, some $47 billion surged into mutual funds tied to stocks and bonds in April, according to the Investment Company Institute. It was the largest influx of money since 2007.


“We’ve been a lot more active in the last six weeks than we were in the last six months,” said Mitchell Slater, a financial adviser at Smith Barney in Florham Park, N.J. “It’s not everybody on the boat, but we’re definitely seeing some of our clients realize, at least in their minds, there’s opportunity now.”

.”

But others returning to the financial casino have not done as well.

....And other investors said in interviews that they had made familiar mistakes: waiting too long to buy, getting in at the top of a small peak, bailing out just before a falling stock turned around.

”




The WSJ had a similar article today headlined

Many Bought Shares High, Sold Low

I think know what the rest of the article is like

Sunday, May 10, 2009

Want Your Portfolio Managed Well Give It to A Woman...





...or someone that thinks like one with regards to investing

Jason Zweig in the WSJ

It is worth pointing out, this Mother's Day weekend, how different things might be if the financial world were female.

Finance professors Brad Barber and Terrance Odean have found that women's risk-adjusted returns beat those of men by an average of about one percentage point annually. In short, women trade less frequently, hold less volatile portfolios and expect lower returns than men do.

On the other hand, in the testosterone-poisoned sandbox of the male investor, the most important thing is beating the other guy; the second most important: bragging about it. The long term is somebody else's problem, and asking for advice is an admission of inferiority. Worrying about risk is for sissies. Leverage is good, since it raises returns -- while the market goes up. Is it any wonder the male-dominated world of Wall Street has boomed and busted every few years for more than two centuries?
....

The results of a nationwide survey of hundreds of investors conducted in March, just days after the Dow bottomed at 6547, show how anger and fear in the minds of men and women can affect their financial decisions. Men were far more likely than women to say they were "more angry than fearful" about the financial crisis. And one in eight men, but only one in every 40 women, had "made riskier investments looking for long-term growth" in the previous week. Female investors were twice as likely to expect the return on stocks over the coming year to be zero or negative and to think stocks will return 5% or less per year over the next 10 years.

"The women were more concerned but took fewer actions," said psychologist Ellen Peters of the University of Oregon, who co-directed the survey. "They were also more pessimistic -- or realistic? -- about what to expect from the market."

Stocks are up 35% since March, so the women's fears haven't yet come to pass. But their inaction already looks wise. And their realism can't hurt, either. "The essential traits and qualities of the male," H.L. Mencken once wrote, "are at the same time the hall-marks of the numskull. ... Women, in fact, are the supreme realists of the race."

Friday, May 8, 2009

Sorry If I'm Not Impressed

NYT Deal Book
May 7, 2009, 5:24 pm
H

Hedge Funds Rise 3.8 Percent in April

Hedge funds posted gains of 3.8 percent in April as the stock market continued its rally and commodities began rising, according to a preliminary report from Hedge Fund Research.

Year-to-date, hedge funds have gained 4.2%, with the best performance coming from firms that specialize in energy and basic materials. Funds that were short the market were hammered in April, falling 7.5 percent on average.

The hedge fund industry faced its worst year on record in 2008, although the average fund still outperformed the overall stock market. Over 1,000 funds were forced to liquidate and halt withdrawals last year.

Firms have also suffered a barrage of criticism from politicians and the public recently, leading many firms to brace for increased regulation
.

Year-to-date, fixed-income/convertible arbitrage funds remained the year’s best performers, returning 5.7 percent last month to put 2009’s advance at around 18 percent. The gains, which were fueled by a general rally in the market, come after the sector was the worst performer last year, falling 35 percent.

Just for Comparison

April Returns for some major indices:

S & P 500 +9.4%
Wilshire 5000 total US market +10.5%
Nasdaq +12.3%
MSCI Emerging Markets +15.6%
EAFE (Developed Foreign) 11.5%

Thursday, May 7, 2009

Here's Some Useless Information

From the WSJ article listing the "top analysts of 2008"

MAY 7, 2009, ET.Best on the Street

In a Difficult Year, Success Is Knowing When to Say Sell

By ANNELENA LOBB
This year's Best on the Street analysts knew when to scream "sell."

Stocks took an epic tumble in 2008, the year covered in the Wall Street Journal's 17th annual analysts survey, as a cascade of bank failures, bailouts and acquisitions rocked the financial system. The Dow Jones Industrial Average lost 33.8% and the S&P 500-stock index fell 38.5%, with most of the turbulence toward the end of the year.

Best on the StreetFor more details and stories about the winning analysts, see The Journal Report coming May 26.
.
Analysts who based their predictions on a gloomy outlook for the banking system and the global economy often turned out to be right. Consumer spending fell sharply. Problems with the housing market rippled through other parts of the economy, and oil prices peaked and sank. The stock pickers who could forecast the storm were the strongest performers.


An amazing surprise: the people chosen in May 2009 as the best analysts of 2008 were those who "knew when to say sell.". Talk about in sample data ! Would one have expected that the people chosen as the top analysts of 2008 have recommended buying stocks throughout last year. Of course the really interesting question would have been: How did the top analysts of 2007 (chosen in may of 2008) do in their forecasts for 2008 ?

Or how about checking on the recent record of this analyst cited in the article:

Across industries, many of the most prescient calls were early sell recommendations. The top computer-and-office equipment analyst, Mark Moskowitz of J.P. Morgan Chase & Co., put a sell on Sun Microsystems in March 2008, anticipating that companies would delay purchases of costly equipment. The shares lost three-quarters of their value though year end.


Sun Microsystems stock has doubled since the beginning of March (see the chart). Did Mr. Moskowitz make a "prescient call" on when to get back into Sun stock ?

Sunday, May 3, 2009

No Surprise Here

The WSJ writes on the adequacy of "monte carlo analysis" routinely used by financial advisors and individuals to "calculate" the probability of the investment accounts successfully finding their retireement needs. The analysis has proven woefully inadequate in achieving its objective since it underestimates the possibility of large declines in investment value. The problem: the assumption of a "bell curve" normal distribution of investment returns which underestimate3s that investment distributions have "fat tails" and "black swan " events occur more frequently in reality than anticipated by the models.

Inadequacy of "bell cuve shaped "probability distributions in financial modelling...sound familiar ?

Saturday, May 2, 2009

This is Scary

The WSJ personal finance blog: The Wallet elaborates on an article in the newspaper (more on the scary advice in that article in another post i will be writing)about financial advisors changing the investing approach in light of the events of last year. I am not averse taking into account recent events. Certainly strategies should take more cognizance of the need for allocations to reliable safe havens for investors, 2 that I use more of than in the past are TIPS and a true hedged fund the Gateway fund (GATEX) which I have written about in the past. But the role of the advisor is to present reasoned changes in strategies. The advice mentioned here seems little more than irrational reaction to recent events. With surverys showing over 80% of investors "unhappy" with their advisors excuse me if I think that many of these strategies are more a short term business strategy for their practice than a long term investment strategy for their clients

Here's one "strategy"

In January, Jerry Verseput, a financial adviser in Sacramento, Cailf., moved from a conventional model using mutual funds to a sector-based approach using ETFs after his portfolios fell significantly in 2008. He decided to make the switch after running an analysis that showed that correlation among the standard asset classes was over 80% over three, five and 10 years—in other words, they weren’t providing adequate diversification.

Now he’s diversifying across nine equity sectors, such as financials, energy and basic materials, technology, and real estate, where the correlation is only about 20%. He’s also using no-load mutual funds to get fixed-income exposure, since bonds throw off regular dividends. Most of his portfolios are up 2% to 2.5% for the year, he says.


I'm not sure what he is referring to, but I did run an 8 year cross correlation of the equity sectors he mentioned. None had a cross correlation of .20 two had correlations of in the 30s .34 for (energy/financials) and .38 for (real estate/energy). I doubt many would expect these low correlations to be the basis of a long term strategy. The other cross correlations ranged from .60 to .79. And it was hardly surprising that it was financials/real estate that had the highest correlation.

Of course if one held all of these sectors anyone knowing anything about equities would know that one simply owned the market. It would also reason that each of these sectors would have high correlations to the overall market, since the most important determinant of a sector's price is the overally market. Thus the correlations of each asset class to the S+P 500 only one was below 70 (69 for energy) one at 79 (reits which are not equities) and the rest in the high 80s.

So to be perfectly forthright, I have no idea what this advisor is talking about except for the short term bond holdings which are in fact an asset class with a low correlation to equities.

The article goes on to describe 2 other strategies with ascending levels of scariness

Mr. Verseput, for example, uses trailing stop-limit orders. If a particular sector drops by a given percentage, then a sell order is automatically generated and the proceeds are moved to cash. “I don’t have to follow the market every single moment, since these [orders] will automatically lock in gains or will allow me to jump into these rallies much earlier,” he says. Another benefit: “It’s a completely unemotional rule. There’s no guesswork involved
.”

This simply a trading strategy and in fact there is quite a bit of guesswork. I also have no idea when he would reverse his sales and get back into the sector. After falling massively the financial sector rallied almost 26% since the end of March and was the best performing sector last month. If Mr Versput sold financials with a stop loss sale several months ago, what is he doing now ?

Also I am not at all sure what he is referring to when he claims his strategy of stop - limit orders both allows him to "lock in gains and jump into rallies earlier". A stop loss limit order is an order to sell when the marke falls to a designated price (to limit losses). If the market drops to the limit level and then reverses course and begins an upward trend, I have no idea how this strategy would allow him to "get into these rallies much earlier." Sorry, it's totally illogical. And of course it's called a stop loss for a reason: since it is below the current market it often locks in a loss rather than locking in a gain. The strategy may impose some discipline (and expose one to whipsaws) it hardly guarantees profits.


The next one is really scary, it reflects basic lack of knowledge of the instrument he plans to use.

Theodore Feight, a financial adviser in Lansing, Mich., has also used stop-loss orders to get clients out of the market for most of 2008 and 2009, and is now talking to clients about using leveraged ETFs to get back in. “The problem we’ve got with the current asset allocation is that it hasn’t evolved,” he says. “The stops allow you to have some protection


Many individual investors have been burned using the leveraged etfs because they don't understand them. But one would expect an advisor to know better.They reflect a multiple of the daily movement in the index not the longer term return one would get in an index fund or etf. Thus the pro shares ultra etf which returns 2x the daily movement is down -8.8% ytd while the S&P 500 is -2.6%. And to make things more aggravating to the investor that doesn't understand the instrument, those who thought using the ultra (2x) etf designed to produce the inverse of the S&P 500 certainly did not give a hedge of the longer term return of the S&P 500. It is -11% ytd, in other words it moved in the same directon of the S&P and produced a return 5x less. Anyone understanding this instrument would conclude it is really only useful for day traders. The idea of an advisor using this as a way to get back into the market (for more than one day) is, to say the least, extremely surprising.

At least saner voices are being voiced by more mainstream observers (except for those hedge funds which are not a reliable "hedge" of anything):

Investors who are unhappy with their financial pro should have “a really intense conversation with their adviser and make sure their adviser understands what they’re looking for and to make sure they’re not missing something their adviser is doing,” says Diahann Lassus, chair of the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors. She says the chief question investors should be asking is: “What are you doing differently to help manage risk?”

“Many advisers are doing things differently,” she says. “We’re building more cash for safety. We’re adding more to short-term bond funds and
hedge-strategy funds.”


Fortunately there are many advisors advocating rational, low cost, long term strategies. While I would allocate client assets somewhat differently, the allocation presented today in WSJ's monthly investing supplement is far from "scary" and is in fact probably the most reasonable of any of the advisor profiles they have presented in this montly supplement.

Sometimes I'm Correct (Although Maybe A Little Early)






I wrote on December 8 that I thought the yield differential between treasuries and highly rated corporated bonds was unsustainable. Using the relevant etfs for corporate bonds (LQD) and the treasuies the yield differential had widened to 3.99% reflecting a flight to quality that pushed the yield to 3.27.

Currently the yield differential is 2.22%, the investor in the LQD would have gained 2.8% the investor in IEF -2.24% (neither number includes the interest earned).

Worth a look at this point might be HYG the high yield etf with a yield of 11.56% (8.29) over treasuties. It has already gained 9.2% since April 8

charts are above.